Wednesday, May 13, 2009

RIP Richard Grasso


Yes,
Richard Grasso. No not Dick Grasso. Rich Grasso, a good friend and uncle died Thursday. Since then I have been struggling to find meaning in what I do.

My Uncle, well, my uncle-in-law, was one heck of a guy who lived life to the fullest. He had so many friends. I remember meeting "The Family" when I was dating my wife and how scared I was......Richard said, don't sweat it, we don't bite......except for Nanny.



He always had a way of making me feel warm and loved. He gave the best hugs and always gave great advice. Unfortunately, he died because he forgot to do one simple thing. He forgot to wear his seat belt. He was thrown from his car and that's what killed him.

It seems to me, after this swine flu thing and now with my uncle.....all of this overbloated hype about genomes saving the world.......is a little too much.

If you look at the fatalities data in 2008 it is crystal clear that the people getting their genomes scanned should pay more attention to whether they are driving safely and buckling up rather than spitting up. Sure we are reducing the rate, but how many really have to die?

Not to say that genomes aren't worthy of study. They are. But Today I want to make sure that each and every reader of this blog, buckles up when they drive. That they forget about using the cell phone in the care. That they decide not to cut off that other driver.........or just stop rushing to beat the light.....


If we all just did that for one day, we could save more lives than any amount of genome scans could......


The Sherpa Says: God Rest Richard Grasso, please learn from his mistake. Drive safely, drive as if getting there late mattered less than getting there alive.......

Monday, May 11, 2009

Thoracic Aortic Aneurysms and Stroke


Today I am writing to bring your attention to another gene found in Thoracic Aortic Aneurysm. There is a nice genetic review on the subject at GeneTests.org


The problem with Aneurysms is that they are essentially ticking time bombs in the body often waiting to explode and ultimately kill you by bleeding in your brain, chest or belly. Kind of makes SNP scans look silly compared to the life and death issues here. In fact, sometimes armed with merely a family history you can find these people and save their lives.

Cardiovascular manifestations of familial thoracic aortic aneurysms and aortic dissections (TAAD) include: (1) dilatation of the aorta at the level of either the ascending aorta or the sinuses of Valsalva; and (2) aneurysms and dissections of the thoracic aorta involving either the ascending or descending aorta. Cardiovascular manifestations are usually the only findings. Affectedindividuals typically have progressive enlargement of the ascending aorta leading to either aortic dissection involving the ascending aorta (type A dissection) or consequent tear or rupture. The onset and rate of progression of aortic dilatation is highly variable.


TAAD is inherited in an autosomal dominant manner with variable expression and decreased penetrance. The majority of individuals diagnosed with familial TAAD have an affected parent. The children of an affected parent are at 50% risk of inheriting the mutant allele and the disorder. Prenatal testing may be available through laboratories offering custom prenatal testing.



I take care of a few patients like this and you may miss this condition, unless you take a good family history. It is often described as "Heart was torn" "Sudden Death" "Abdominal Aneurysm" or even "Heart Attack"


This is why I am all about getting your family history, but then reviewing it with a medical professional. Most of our patients come back, time and time again bringing new medical information. This helps us best treat and prevent disease. In the case of TAAD, if your sister or brother or mother or father had the syndrome, you are at 50-50 odds of having it too.

Since often the only signs and symptoms are chest pain and sudden death.......It helps to have a surveillance plan. But how do we diagnose these patients?

TAAD is diagnosed based on the presence of dilatation and/or dissection of the thoracic aorta, absence of Marfan syndrome and other connective tissue abnormalities, and presence of a positive family history. TGFBR2 (encoding transforming growth factor beta receptor type II), TGFBR1 (encoding transforming growth factor beta receptor type I), MYH11 (encoding myosin-11), ACTA2(encoding alpha 2 actin, aortic smooth muscle), and two loci, FAA1 and TAAD1, are known to be associated with TAAD. Further locus heterogeneity is evident. Molecular genetic testing for TGFBR1, TGFBR2,MYH11, and ACTA2 is available clinically. Molecular genetic testing for the other the loci are currently performed on a research basis only.

One of my families with this condition actually also has a strong family history of stroke. Traditionally, we thought that this TAAD didn't involve other vascular issues. We were once again, proven absolutely wrong.

Dianna M Milewicz, MD, PhD recently discovered in a familial cohort, relation between ACTA2 and TAAD with stroke.

"Mutations in Smooth Muscle Alpha-Actin (ACTA2) Cause Early Onset Coronary Artery Disease, Stroke and Moyamoya Disease, Along with Thoracic Aortic Aneurysms and Dissections," is published early online in the American Journal of Human Genetics.
This just goes to show that assumptions are often false, which is why most GWAS come back false in the end. Because assumptions about not having assumptions can lead us even further astray. With ACTA2 I wonder why we didn't think this smooth muscle gene was a candidate before.

So what do we do to defuse the ticking bomb?

Surveillance

Echocardiography should be performed at frequent intervals to monitor the status of the ascending aorta.

  • Yearly examinations are sufficient with relatively small aortic dimensions and slow rates of aortic dilatation.


  • More frequent examinations are indicated in any of the following situations:


    • The aortic root exceeds about 4.5 centimeters in adults.


    • The rate of aortic growth exceeds about 0.5 cm per year.


    • Significant aortic regurgitation occurs.

The entire aorta should be imaged every few years, as the incidence of aneurysms in other portions of the aorta may be as high as 20%.

After repair of the ascending aorta, the remaining portion of the aorta needs to be routinely imaged for enlargement of the distal aorta, whether the individual had a type A dissection initially or underwent prophylactic repair of the ascending aorta.


Periodic imaging of the cerebral circulation in individuals with a TGFBR2 mutation to evaluate for cerebral aneurysms is recommended as these aneurysms may occur later in life.


Hemodynamic stress. Medications that reduce hemodynamic stress, such as beta adrenergic blocking agents, are routinely prescribed for individuals with the Marfan syndrome, and similar treatment is recommended for individuals with familial TAAD [Shores et al 1994]. Aortic dissection is exceedingly rare in early childhood, but aortic dilatation may be present in childhood. Medical therapy should be considered in children and adults with aortic dilatation.

Hypertension should be aggressively treated and controlled in individuals with TAAD.

Prophylactic surgical repair of the aorta to prevent subsequent dissection or rupture is indicated in any of the following situations

  • When the rate of dilation approaches 1.0 cm per year


  • When aortic regurgitation progresses


  • For individuals with familial TAAD caused by TGFBR2 mutations before the diameter of the ascending aorta reaches 5.0 cm

  • For those with bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) when the diameter of the ascending aorta is 5.0 cm


  • For all others with TAAD, when the diameter of the ascending aorta is between 5.0 cm and 5.5 cm

More recently, a valve-sparing procedure has been developed that precludes the need for chronic anticoagulation [David et al 1999].

More aggressive surgical repair may be indicated for individuals with a family history of aortic dissection without significant aortic root enlargement and in individuals with TGFBR2 mutations.

You can see that this watchful waiting and action when indicated pathway is very similar to other things we do, including BRCA positive surveillance options. This is why genomic medicine will win in the end. We will catch those who have these horrible time bombs and help prevent them. In my mind that is a home run every time. Will testing take place before a good family history? Only if we don't have the skilled manpower to take good histories and physicals.......

The Sherpa Says: I just discovered another one of these families last week. I will say it again and again. You miss 100% of putts you leave short. I.E. if you don't look, you never find.

Friday, May 8, 2009

Friday's Doctor using clinically unvalidated tests...


Dr Turrisi,

An otherwise fine doctor, I am certain, has decided to use a clinically unvalidated tool in his practice. It is known as the Navigenics Health Compass. You can find him here. Or here on Vitals.com

Like I said before. I will highlight each and every one of these doctors who are using a clinically unvalidated tool to treat patients. Since Navigenics has decided to put it on the record. I will as well. Dr. Turrisi is one of 31 physicians in the MDVIP network who are using this test. Or at least claim to be.


Dr Turrisi is a Pulmonlogist and an Internist. He went to medical school in 1978. I wonder how much has changed in the field of genetics since then?


The Sherpa Says: MDVIP consists of 280 primary care physicians who serve more than 100,000 patients nationwide. I wonder why 10% are using this test? I know why 90% are not. What would you do clinically with different results? Could you do something differently based on the results?

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

An Easy Way to Find Overconfident and Dangerous Physicians.


I always wonderd who would admit to using the cliniclaly unvalidated SNP chips into their medical practice as if it were standard practice, without having any training at all in genetics.

Do you remember my blog post 2 years ago entitled "Beware Physicians Bearing Genetic Tests"

Basically I state that if you have not had any training interpreting genetic testing, you are likely to make a hash of it. This is especially true with the highly probabilistic and non-clinically validated SNP scans.


So just when I wonder who in their right mind would admit to using this as a clinical tool without any validation......Navigenics makes it easy to find the krazies!!! From the site.


"Find a physician"


A growing number of doctors have collaborated with Navigenics to integrate genetic testing into their medical practices. Through these relationships, Navigenics’ genetic testing services are available through affiliated physicians to help patients understand their genetic risk factors for disease and work with their doctors to develop individualized prevention plans."


The site then goes on further....


Navigenics does not endorse any particular physician or attest to their ability.


That is about the smartest thing I heard out of their mouth all day. Obviously, who are you to attest to their ability. But One thing is for sure. These doctors are certainly overconfident, by using non clinically validated tools in their clinical care.....Sheesh.....


I can imagine a Malpractice lawyer now.......

Lawyer- "Why did you suggest a cath in this patient with no risk factors?"

Doctor-He has a genetic predisposition in 9p21.3"


Lawyer-"Predisposition? Says Who?"

Doctor-"Navigenics"

Lawyer-"Is Navigenics a medical professional organization with criteria and guidelines?"

Doctor-silence

Lawyer-"Was a cath clinically validated as a means to prevent a heart attack in this patient with 9p21.3 SNP changes?"

Doctor-silence

Lawyer-"Why did you subject your patient to a risky procedure because of nonclinically validated test results???"


If I were an MDVIP patient, I would leave this organization and run for the hills. If they are willing to let a clinically unvalidated tool into their doctors offices, this speaks volumes of their lack of clinical judgement. Who would pay for that kind of care???? Who would deliver that care? 31 doctors according to the site.......31 of hundreds of thousands.....My question to these guys, what would they do clinically different with Navigenics Tests? Would they do anything different? If they are, I would love to hear their testimonials of how they use this test in their practice.
Does anyone have the contact information for him?

The Sherpa Says: Like I said, Beware Doctors Bearing Genetic Tests.....Now we have a list of the Krazies, Thanks Navigenics! Here's one of 'em I plan on profiling each and everyone of these......Until MDVIP comes to their clinical senses.

Lots to recap today.


First, in support of Francis Collins' efforts. I am a God believing scientist/physician. Why? Can you explain "spooky science" of photons? No? Are there some things in this world which are a mystery? Yes. I choose God to explain that mystery for me.

Because as a human it is beyond my ability to conceive of it. Maybe someday Singularity will "save me" but I doubt it.

Second, To explain Germany's move without resorting to "It's designed to make doctors money"

Which BTW is the stupidest argument I have ever heard coming from a country with Nationalized Medicine. Doctors make what they make and that's all. Why try to find new revenue streams for someone who's salary is capped? Do they really think this would bring Doctors to their country? Wrong!


Here's why they are outlawing this and why comparative effectiveness research in the US will end up costing some useful therapies their market.


Think that the person is not an individual, instead it is a money making machine for the largest company in your country. The government. The government makes its money through taxes.....it expends its capital supporting people who aren't so good at paying taxes as well as a whole host of other things, like defending you from nasty people looking to destroy your way of life. Why do they support those who don't have jobs and aren't healthy? They do this in hopes to get them stable enough to pay taxes again. Thus a new revenue stream is created.


If they can keep you healthy so you pay taxes, that is a big win. If they can do that with minimal amount of cost, that is a huge win. So when the government, which controls the doctors in a Nationalized Healthcare Country BTW, sees a demand for a test, which has unproven benefit and is likely to increase demand for further healthcare services: "I have a 9p21.3 SNP and now I think I have chest pain"........They look for ways to stem the tide of this cost.


Thus they expend less to keep you as healthy as physicians are scientifically capable of doing TODAY......maybe someday this testing will be clinically useful....but not yet. At least not for most of it.


In fact, I chuckled when 23andME went to Davos to woo, Europeans. Their healthcare is even more pragmatic than ours in the US. So this move by Germany is aimed at stemming costs not to make more money for doctors.......Which BTW, if everyone was acting on this SNP info, we would have a ton more procedures.....which would in the end make more money for MDs in the US.....which is why this whole, gatekeeper business is about the most ignorant argument I have ever heard......


Lastly, Medicare has opted to not pay for CYP2C9 and VKORC1 testing for warfarin dosing. I am certain you may have read about it, but here's the spin......despite having good evidence behind its benefits, it wasn't ENOUGH benefit for the US Government to pay......Despite being ENOUGH for the FDA to put it on the box.....


Do you see where I am headed? Yes, despite an article in the New England Journal saying Comparative Effectiveness Research will be a good thing for Personalized Medicine(article to come out tomorrow), we may actually have the opposite effect. At least until the costs of sequencing comes down to less than a Chest Xray.


Ah yes, everyone would like to know that they get the Maximum Benefit to Cost ratio, but sometime you just have to ask yourself..........are leeches that much cheaper than phlebotomy? That is the problem with Comparative Effectiveness when you put cost into the mix. Which is precisely what the government is paying for........Why wouldn't they? I just told you why they would be interested in this. I am interested in this. Who wouldn't be?


I guess the people who bid for the KNOME GENOME on Ebay, that's who....


The Sherpa Says: Congrats to the girls at 23andMe who managed to get listed on the same top beautiful people list an Sully. That is a PR feat, to get them listed alongside someone who actually saved lives of people in a tremendously heroic feat........I hate marketing and fluff journalism! Shame on you Tonic....You actually listed them ABOVE Sully! Maybe that's why MDV Divested from 23andME.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

In My Inbox........


I think maybe the government of Germany has been receiving the same emails as myself. You see, in case you missed it, Germany is banning Direct To Consumer testing of DNA. This is something that I have been covering for almost 2 years now.....not the Germany thing but the whole regulation of what could be construed to be the practice of medicine.

Why do I think Angie Merkel has been getting the same emails as me? Well, take a look at my inbox-

"There is a new comment on the post "How to Fake a DNA Test".http://www.eyeondna.com/2008/04/13/how-to-fake-a-dna-test/


Author: Scooter Jones Comment:If someone wants to fake a DNA test would it work if he put someone elses saliva, sperm or blood in his mouth prior to being tested.?"

A while back I said that people could potentially "fake" a DNA test, planting DNA at a crime scene, etc.

It turns out 'Ol Scooter is trying to figure out whether Sperm, Blood or Spit is the best way to go......Too Bad he doesn't know that it's awfully tough to "spit" sperm or blood into a vacutainer tube.......

Maybe he could just bid on one of those Whoel Genome Scans that KNOME is offering.........too late :(

These DTC companies better hurry up before the US does the same thing as Germany's law

"Under the law, genetic tests can only be carried out by a doctor and require the full consent of all parties involved.


In addition it prohibits the use of genetic testing for indications of a predisposition to illnesses that appear only later in life, such as breast cancer or diseases of the nervous system."


The Sherpa Says: With guys like Scooter out there, it makes a lot of sense to follow Germany's line. These days we seem to be pro-regulation anyways......... I think I hear Agent Smith at the door now.....

Friday, May 1, 2009

Dr Topol, I agree with you. Patient empowerment is key.


Dr. Topol, who like myself is involved in a Cohort analysis of SNP scans and their effects on health behaviors has a video blog post about the recent Bad Press that SNP scans have gotten.

More importantly, the bad press that DTC genomic companies have gotten. For full disclosure, I am not affiliated with ANY of the DTC SNP scan companies BTW, CPMC was the first study of this kind, not Scripps.

Dr Topol says that there are articles which were published in the NEJM and they were reviewed by me a week or so ago......These articles obviously have caused "consternation"

He states that he approaches this from several perspectives and addresses his research.

There is the "Nihilistic Approach" that if you have an OR of 2 or greater that it is likely that this risk science is not going to go away and he asks "When is the right time to have this information?"

He says there is no real answer to this. And that there needs to be more research on missing hereditary components.....

Then he says he has the "By having this information and Empowering patients, you help them" approach

"That may be a good thing"

Well, here's my take. There are several different data points which are much more predictive, powerful AND CLINICALLY VALIDATED than these SNP scans which can cost upwards of 2500 USD. Let's see....how about Blood pressure? Body Mass Index? CRP? Family History?

The Whole Genome SNP scan is for research, not a business plan, not for clinical medicine.........or for a Venture Investment.

The Sherpa Says: By empowering patients, we help prevent disease. But by telling patients information that may be proven wrong tomorrow, I am not so sure that helps establish patient rapport. Encouraging patients to go out and spend 2500 USD in this economy on something that is relatively useless is the specialty of silver tongued salesmen and marketers like Bernie Madoff. Isn't that what got all of us into this economic disaster in the first place????