Showing posts with label mdvip. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mdvip. Show all posts

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Scuttling Navi'


It looks to me that Navi will be scuttled. I am fairly certain of that. My guess is that more and more toxic assets will be dumped into Navi and that it will go bye-bye



Well, we just found out why it is a "Bad Asset" and I have just decided that someone was being untruthful....

It turns out that it was Navi......sucking up a troubled asset to protect Affy. 
Why? Navi is now getting sued for 75 million due to patent infringement. To look at the case, you can read about it at Justia

Why would you buy a lab which could be and has already been proven to be subject of a lawsuit?

Navi is a pawn and I feel bad for their employees. Man were they suckered. Listen employees of Navi, if you want to make a real company, give me a call......

I wonder how many startups are designed for failure. This is just a huge shell game with really rich people.......VCs have multiple start ups so that they can protect their other real investments....

Just like the ThunderDome.......2 men enter, 1 man leaves.....


The Sherpa Says: If Navi lives for another year it will be to protect the investment of VCs other investments.....Sorry it had to come to that, but hey, that's business.....Now the real question lingers......When Navi goes, who will own the computerized records of its research participants or its customers?

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

DTC Genomic tests? Who's that?


The American College of Physicians is perhaps getting the act together.....

Recently I sent an article to the ACP President Jeffrey Harris, I scolded him about how short sighted it was not to include topics on Genetics at the ACP conference in April. I still have received no response back from him......

BUT......

It appears the ACP is looking for Internists who have experiences with DTC Genomic testing.

Your thoughts exactly: direct-to-consumer genetic tests

ACP Internist is assessing how often internists are asked by patients about direct-to-consumer genetic tests.

Tell us about your experiences.
Learn more about the impact of direct-to-consumer genetic tests
here and here.

They link to an article from Greg Feero. In which he says:

"This amounts to DTC marketing of the genetic equivalent of a full-body CT scan"
Is that what MDVIP is doing? Now imagine them doing the full body CT without a radiologists interpretation........ That is exactly what MDVIP is doing......

This is the image of DTC which will now be painted in the Internal Medicine Doctor's mind. Too bad that they will apply this image to ALL genetic testing :(


The Sherpa Says: ACP, you may be coming around.....but a 3 question Survey Monkey effort is hardly what I call real effort....

Thursday, February 5, 2009

What will it add???? Huh Ed?


"MDVIP doctors “are very enthused and very interested in what this is going to add clinically to their management of the patient,” MDVIP CEO Edward Goldman told Pharmacogenomics Reporter this week."

That from a report by GenomeWeb's Turna Ray yesterday. (Subscription needed...bummer)

That is a superb question to be interested in Ed.....

What will Navigenics' Annual Insight test add clinically to the care of patients?????

The short answer: We have no clue.

That being said, have doctors done things on or to patients in which they had no clue what the outcome is likely to be?

Yes, it is called medical research. What it's not, is standard of care, even more, it's not concierge care. That's for certain. The team at MDVIP should be focused on taking family histories, med-med reconciliation and med-gene interactions. They should not be trying to integrate a test which has no clinical validity.

We have been studying family history and its role in medicine for decades now......so why did they jump at this shiny bobble????

I am not certain, other than they consider this a "patch" so that they can say they are practicing personalized medicine.


Let me speak clearly to Ed Goldman. "This test is not personalized medicine" In fact it is the antithesis of that. Why? Well, you are applying a test to people who may not derive use from it, even worse you are not personalizing whether you use the test or not.......


True personalized medicine is finding a family history of heart disease, anticipating the patient's risk, getting them on a good exercise regimen, and maybe even testing CYP 2C9, 2D6 and 2C19 in anticipation of a beta blocker, warfarin and perhaps plavix......

That is what personalized medicine is ladies and gentlemen. It is hard work, and not exactly scalable, but it is what is required to carry out truly preventative medicine. Not some shiny bobble.....

IMHO, MDVIP may have sullied their name by telling patients that they don't care about what the AMA says or even that this test has no proven clinical utility.....hell, even PSA has some utility!!!!

From the article:

"Of the MDVIP physicians surveyed, more than 90 percent said that genetic risk information changed how they handled their patients and spurred them to take a more aggressive medical approach."

My point exactly, why in the hell would these test results indicate that you should manage patients more aggressively? Maybe if you have enrolled them in an experiment, and obtained informed consent, you might be able to do that.....but 9p21.3 doesn't add anything to the clinical risk profile......perhaps these 90% of doctors need a course or two in clinical genetics and biostatistics.....

What a shame, these doctors were suckered in by the razzle dazzle and now are inappropriately up-managing patients based on scientifically valid (sometimes) yet clinically invalid data......

From the article

"On the one hand, Navigenics employs state-licensed physicians and genetic counselors, but maintains in its Terms of Service that this does not constitute a doctor-patient relationship. "

Shrouded in a veil of mystery and now trying to pose as clinically valid without taking responsibility.......

Well, it is no mystery that these tests are not clinically validated, or that they even produce beneficial behavioral outcomes.......

“Our stance has always been that patients shouldn't take this information and make medical decisions on their own, that they should consult a doctor,” Navigenics’ Vanier said. “This is complex information that is often challenging for physicians.”

Is that why you picked a bunch of concierge physicians who aren't trained at all in genetics to "Beta Test" the service?

“Navigenics assumes no responsibility for any consequence relating directly or indirectly to any action or inaction you take based on our site, the services, your report, or other content,” the company says on its website. “You must evaluate and bear all risks associated with their use, including any reliance on their accuracy, completeness, or usefulness.”

Of course not, why take any responsibility for what you bring to market???

Maybe MDVIP knows this and that's why the Navigenics partnership isn't on their front page

From their site:

"The truth is, MDVIP goes far beyond the fee for access companies that are rightfully seen as Concierge Healthcare and is actually setting the new gold standard for healthcare. "

If Navigenics SNP scans without any clinically valid data are the gold standard, then get me the hell out of medicine. Maybe MDVIP, should research the subject and perhaps participate in ethical research in the field???
You would have figured these companies would have funded studies prior to forcing a non clinical test on clinicians........


The Sherpa Says: This is just another case of razzle dazzle without taking moral responsibility for ones corporate actions. Haven't we had enough corporate chicanery lately????