Showing posts with label think gene. Show all posts
Showing posts with label think gene. Show all posts

Monday, May 17, 2010

Potential of genomic medicine, LOST

I was reading and often read Mark Henderson of the Times



The piece basically comes down to one conclusion.

We have no proof that most of this stuff is useful in any form.

This is something that I have been shouting from the roof tops ever since some self deluded socialite from Mountain View decided to say "Genetic testing is for fun"

Seriously DTCG. You knew this day was coming. You tried to play yourself off as hip, cool, sexy/ Yet at the same time to avoid regulation you played, not serious, not clinical, and in essence, not valuable.

I was deeply concerned about precisely this issue. By putting yourselves out there as an invalid in the clinical world, you cheapened the field and some of the tests that you offered.

Because of this conglomeration of useless with useful, the field of medicine and healthcare as a whole needs to create systems to sift between marketing and PR spin/hype from truth and medical utility.

Luckily in the US we have such a system EGAPP. We also have things such as the CPMC ICOB. But in England, they have no such official system.

What is even more troublesome is the lack of clinical utility of such tests and lack of funding to evaluate the utility. The problem with this rush to market the next GWAS is emblematic of this over hype cycle that exists in medical science.

Why?

Medical scientific discovery can or cannot be useful in medicine.

That is all.

Saying something promotes "Health" rather than treats,cures, prevents or diagnoses disease to avoid regulation confuses the public and unsophisticated venture capital. Which really makes me wonder if that is what you had intended in the first place........

What should have been said is "These tests have not been proven to prevent/diagnose/treat disease nor have they been proven to aid in healthcare"

But that probably wouldn't have sold many kits......Thus the problem with medicine, you can't just "fake it" with Time Magazine.......

What your "faking it" has done is created a hornets nest on both sides of the pond with governments scrambling to decide what matters.

"Caroline Wright, head of science at the PHG Foundation, said: “The heart of the problem is that we do not have enough data on whether these tests actually help patient care. We desperately need the equivalent of clinical trials for diagnostics."

Further, the UK doesn't have a team equivalent to EGAPP over here. Which BTW, K.O. if you are listening, I would love to be a part of..."I'm just saying......"

We need to ask ourselves as Andrew Yates points out, what results can we expect when the average death percentage over time in this country or any others is 100%

Will a flashy test keep you alive longer? Not if it has no clinical data proving that it does.

No amount of blimps and SoHo parties will prevent death or disease. Sorry.

The Sherpa Says: The Quake paper was their best shot of integrating this into clinical care and they are arguing about whether or not to put him on a prophylactic statin? Which BTW has no evidence behind it........Personally I think that shot was misfired......

Thursday, March 12, 2009

23andME to do research. One question lingers....


Did you guys catch that Sergey Brin is funding some research into Parkinsons Disease? It turns out that you can have all the money in the world and still get disease.......Or at least pre-disease...

"The study, will be conducted by 23andMe, a company co-founded and co-managed by Mr. Brin’s wife, Anne Wojcicki. The company offers a personal genomics service, in which it scans the DNA submitted by its customers and provides information on their health risks, ancestry and other traits."

There are a couple of issues I need clarified here.

1. Is there an IRB involved to govern 23andME in this "research"?


23andMe will establish a research advisory committee to guide such collaborations. 23andMe may grant researchers associated with partner organizations access to our database of genetic and other contributed personal information. We will ensure that such research partners obtain clearance from institutional review boards, as appropriate, and agree to maintain confidentiality consistent with our privacy statement.

But Not 23andMe. Just their partners.......


2. Is there a cost or coercion involved?


The people with Parkinson’s disease who enter the study would receive the same analysis of their DNA as other 23andMe customers, but would pay only $25 instead of the usual $399.


3. What is so unique about what they are doing?

“The only thing that is remarkable is that there is a very rich man who is going to fund it,” Dr. Stefansson said.
hehehehe.....Oh Kari......

4. Will the research involve special subjects, like children?

“Babies can’t spit into a tube,” Mr. Brin said


I am pretty sure you can fix that Sergey.........


The Sherpa Says: The Buddha is right........you can't escape death. Unless you realize that there is no gene. Do me a favor Mr Brin. Have your wife create an IRB for your new "Research Institution"

Monday, September 15, 2008

Democratization? Or Capitalization? Take yer pick

An old post.......interesting that I seemed to be right on track....In reading through my RSS feeder over a year ago now I stumbled across an interesting video at Testing Hiatus. It comes from the website Master Plan the Movie. This is especially timely given the new shiny 399 USD SNP scan.....which BTW is still more expensive than Coriell's Free Scan!

Before you watch this YouTube video I first would like you to take a gander at an excerpt from "The Google Story"


Sergey Brin and Larry Page have ambitious long-term plans for Google's expansion into the fields of biology and genetics through the fusion of science, medicine, and technology. . . .One of the most exciting Google projects involves biological and genetic research that could foster important medical and scientific breakthroughs. Through this effort, Google may help accelerate the era of personalized medicine, in which understanding an individual's precise genetic makeup can contribute to the ability of physicians and counselors to tailor health care treatment, rather than dispensing medications or recommending treatments based on statistics or averages.


"We need to use the largest computers in the world," Venter said. "Larry and Sergey have been excited about our work and about giving us access to their computers and their algorithm guys and scientists to improve the process of analyzing data. It shows the broadness of their thinking. Genetic information is going to be the leading edge of information that is going to change the world. Working with Google, we are trying to generate a gene catalogue to characterize all the genes on the planet and understand their evolutionary development. Geneticists have wanted to do this for generations."

Over time, Venter said, Google will build up a genetic database, analyze it, and find meaningful correlations for individuals and populations. . . . Google's data-mining techniques appear well-suited to the formidable challenges posed by analyzing the genetic sequence.It has begun work on this project, but has not been required to disclose any information about it publicly since the work has no impact on its current revenue and profits."

People will be able to log on to a Google site using search capacities and have the ability to understand things about themselves as they change in real time," Venter said. "What does it mean to have this variation in genes? What else is known?

And instead of having a few elitist scientists doing this and dictating to the world what it means, with Google it would be creating several million scientists."Google has empowered individuals to do searches and get information and have things in seconds at their fingertips," he went on.

"Where is that more important than understanding our own biology and its connection to disease and behavior? With Google, you will be able to get an understanding of your own genes. Google has the capacity to do all of this, and it is one of the discussions I have had with Larry and Sergey."


Ok, So now you can watch the movie at Testing Hiatus Let me know what you think. Does Don't be Evil mean Be Good? Or Does it mean something else?

The Sherpa Says: 23andME has been in the works long before it hit the radar. See Russ Altman earn his advisorship to 23 and Me here. Lastly, there will be only one purchaser of 23andMe's data.....Google....end of story.